Relationships

August 4, 2011

Forcing Family Violence out of the Closet

More articles by »
Written by: Kristi
Tags: , , ,
rihanna-eminem-love-the-way-you-lie-vid

Thanks to the media, legislative change and the extensive hard work of many passionate individuals, our social consciousness has begun to accept that queer relationships are fundementally very similar to straight relationships.

Queers deal with flirting, rejection, break-ups and infidelities; we can all fall in love, fall out of love, get our hearts broken, get married, have kids, get divorced, etc. One aspect of queer relationships and queer love that is on par with straight relationships but hardly acknowledged are the realities of family violence. It’s sad to say, but LGBTQ people suffering an abusive relationship are often ignored, by everyone. The straight establishment often fails to understand abuse within a queer relationship (ie. what happens when two women in a relationship claim the other is abusive and call the same shelter looking for a bed?) and the gay community is often hesitant to acknowledge this darker side of queer love when socially and legally fighting for legal recognition of their relationships (aka presenting the rosiest picture possible to the cons).

I’m going to be using the word “abuser” for the person using violence, and the word “victim” for the person who is experiencing the violence for simplicities sake. But please understand that I acknowledge that both people, abuser and victim, are complex individuals whose lives expand beyond these labels.

Is It Family Violence?

Family Violence, also known as Domestic Violence, Domestic Abuse and Intimate Partner Violence, is the systemic (on-going), unilateral (going one-way) use of single or multiple forms of violence by the abuser to gain power and control over the victim. It is not mutual, it is not consensual and it is not justifiable. It often escalates over time, and can have a profound, lasting impact on any children who are witness to it. There are many types of violence that could be used by an abuser to get what they want from the victim:

Physical

This is the most recognized form of violence in abusive relationships. Physical violence can include hitting, kicking, slapping, pinching, hair-pulling, pushing, shoving, restraining or physically preventing the victim from moving or leaving, choking or using a weapon against the victim.

Emotional/Verbal 

Using putdowns, insults, criticism, isolating the victim from friends, family and the community, blackmailing the victim, false accusations, humiliating and doing other things for the purpose of lowering the victim’s self-esteem. In queer relationships, this could also mean threatening to out a partner who isn’t openly gay.

Sexualized 

Forcing or coercing the victim to accept or perform unwanted sexual acts, forcing or coercing the victim to accept or perform unwanted sexual acts for money or gifts, filming an unconsenting partner in a consensual or unconsensual sexual act or performing sexual acts on a partner who is asleep or intoxicated to the point they cannot consent. Sexualized violence is NOT sex; it is using sexual acts as a weapon. This also includes refusing the victim access to or use of safer sex information or birth control (including condoms)

Financial 

Controlling the victim’s assets and income, demanding money, threatening or committing extortion, controlling the victim’s financial autonomy and work and forcing the victim to sell or buy goods and services.

Threatening 

Threatening to harm the victim, people the victim cares about, the victim’s pets or the victim’s property.

Damaging Property

Damaging or destroying the victim’s property and harming or killing the victim’s pets.

Neglect 

This mostly applies to relationships where one or both persons are suffering from chronic health conditions or disabilities. Denying the ill or disabled person of their medications or support equipment, stealing these items and preventing the victim from accessing appropriate medical and psychiatric care.

No, It Isn’t Just A Bad Temper

Family Violence is not caused by anger, a ‘bad temper’, their own past victimization, alcohol or drugs; the abuser chooses to use violence to get what they want. We know this because the abuser can maintain control of their ‘anger’ or ‘alcohol’ in situations where it won’t serve their purpse to ‘blow up’ (they won’t punch their boss if she pisses them off and they won’t start punching the victim in the middle of a crowded supermarket). That does not mean that the abuser is a bad person; it means that they are making bad decisions, and they can choose not to use violence. But this needs to be their choice. No amount of pleading, asking or complying with the abuser’s demands will guarantee that they will decide not to use violence.

Why Don’t They Leave?

A lot of people who know someone who is a victim of Family Violence ask “Why don’t they just leave”? Watching a friend or family member being victimized is just awful, and it can be very frustrating to watch someone you care about suffering and ‘deciding’ to stay with an abusive partner. But victims of family violence don’t often have as many choices as we’d like to think. They may love their abuser genuinely and hold out hope that they may change one day (as many abusers often claim that the abuse will stop many times). If they suffer from low self-esteem they may feel like no one else will ever want them. If the couple has children together the victim may not want to break up their family. He or she may rely on their abuser for financial support, and fear that they will not be able to support themselves financially, especially if they lack education or employable skills. They may lack access to a suitable emergency shelter (especially true for gay or male-identified men), housing, emotional or social supports.

The Queer Reality

All of these facts are multiplied for queer people who are in the closet and fear exposure and the loss of their partner, and for people living in areas that are unfriendly or unsupportive to LGBTQ people. Gay victims of Family Violence may also experience isolation from the LGBTQ community, that at times may try to stifle any negative aspects of queer relationships in their efforts to paint a rosey, defendable image to conservative legal opponants. Additionally, the victim may be afraid to leave the abuser. It is a statistical fact that the most dangerous time for a victim is after they leave their partner. During this period they are mostly likely to be physically harmed, maimed or killed by their partner.

But, it’s a misconception that victims are passive participants in their own abuse. Victims of violence, any violence (whether raped by a stranger, attacked in a bar or abused by a partner) will take physical, verbal and emotional actions to resist, minimize or stop the violence. This resistance is a crucial componant of their self-preservation, used to preserve and protect their dignity as a human being. A man being assualted with a baseball bat by his lover may put up his arms to protect his head; a woman receiving daily and unrelenting criticism about the food she cooks for her wife may just stop making any, and a person being raped by a person they love may close their eyes and imagine they are somewhere else. A person experiencing systemic family violence may also appear to align themselves with their abuser in court, when questioned by the cops or family and friends (knowing that if they don’t, they’ll get it later). Their resistance must be honoured and acknowledged if we are to provide useful support.

So, what can you do if someone you love is a victim of family violence? The most important thing to remember is to be non-judgemental. When I talk about judgement here, I’m talking about the attitude that you a) understand their situation as well or better than they do and b) know the best solution for their problem. If you pass judgment on your loved one through either words or actions, it is not likely that they will confide in you or ask you for help when they need it. You need to accept that they know their situation the best (ie. they know if it’s too dangerous to leave their partner) and that they are responsible for their own choices just like the abuser. The best you can do is lend a supportive ear, offer any help you can, learn about family violence and talk to them about it. Let them know that you are there for them, and that you will support them with their decisions. Sometimes just knowing that someone’s got your back can be a big self-confidence boost.

You can also support victims by suggesting and helping them to create a safety plan. This is a plan that they (and their children) can use to escape when their partner becomes violent. Making sure all important documents (birth certificates, SIN cards, Band Status cards, insurance papers, mortgage papers, leases, etc) are all in one place and easy to grab if they need to leave, and having an emergency stash of money in a separate bank account or with a trusted friend.

If you are, or think you may be, in an abusive relationship, there are many different supports available to you and any children you may have, whether you choose to leave or stay with your partner. And contrary to popular belief, unless you have children who are in danger, your choice not to go to the police about the abuse will be respected by most family violence supports. There are also supports available to abusive people who want to change their behaviour but aren’t sure how. Below are a few places to get started; remember that even if you don’t live in one of these cities, most have 1-800 numbers that you can call toll free and they will help refer you to services closer to home. Remember that you can always contact your local LGBTQ/Pride centre, University and college LGBTQ supports, counselling centres and women’s centres, any Family Violence shelter or your closest YWCA (that’s yWca not yMca).

Provincial/Territorial Government pages on Family Violence with resource listings:

British Columbia, Alberta, Saskatchewan, Manitoba, Ontario, Quebec, Newfoundland, Nova Scotia, New Brunswick, PEI, Nunavut, Yukon, NWT

Hot Peaches – A great info site and directory for services within Canada and around the globe

Discussion Paper on Family Violence in Gay male relationships from the Government of Canada – lists resources, myths about family violence in gay relationships and websites with more information

Directory of Services for men who are victims of Family Violence – listed by province/city

Discussion Paper on Family Violence in Lesbian relationships from the Government of Canada – a little bit older, but great information nonetheless

Directory of Services for men who abuse their partners – listed by province/city

Directory of Transitional Housing and Shelters for abused women – some of these resources are available to men, and will often referr to other services if not.

Photo Credit: Love The Way You Lie by Rihanna and Eminem



About the Author

Kristi
Kristi
|Sex & Relationships Writer| I am a 20-something straight divorcee with a dirty mind and a loud mouth. I work for a non-profit organization that can appreciate my mad writing and policy development skills despite my outrageous TMI outbursts. I'm a feminist, a mother, a techno-phile, an avid and shameless sex blogger. I'm most often seen having sex or hunched over a computer, writing about sex. Or eating...I like eating.




 
 

 
NYC1

The Big Apple on a Small Budget

Being a full-time university student, living on your own and being entirely self-sufficient is hard! And you’re pretty much screwed when it comes to traveling. Friends who still live at home can afford to go to Cuba, Eur...
by Sarah
4

 
 
Screen shot 2012-10-19 at 1.26.27 PM

Trouble in (Queer) Paradise: What Does It Take To Be Different After Dark?

There’s something in the Montreal soil that keeps bearing the raddest fruit. The newly minted queer collective, going by the name of Trouble is throwing it’s first of many dance party fundraisers for ACCM (AIDS Community Ca...
by Ian
2

 
 
ellen

Hillary Clinton Appoints Ellen Degeneres as Global HIV/AIDS Envoy

Who better to spread the word of an “AIDS -free generation”? Our beloved lesbian sister Ellen Degeneres was appointed Global HIV/AIDS Envoy by the equally awesome Secretary of State Hillary Clinton. The announcemen...
by Dallas
0

 

 
kim

An Open Letter to Kim Kardashian

By Divine Grace Dearest Kimberly, Please allow me to preface this letter by congratulating you on finding someone to read it to you. I can only imagine how difficult it must be to learn how to read between all of those dress fi...
by Team Gaily
2

 
 
Seuss

Elton, Seuss And Others on Coming Out, Why It’s Ok Out Here

Did you know that yesterday was National Coming Out Day? Did you come out? If you were already out did you declare your homo-ness to the masses? Well, in a world that generally worships those in Famousland, celebrities often ac...
by Dallas
3

 
 
harper-ford-toronto-politics2

Toronto’s Fordian Parallel Universe/Empire

I recently came across a video on FB with insider footage of Rob Ford hosting a barbeque, with guest speaker Stephen Harper. In it, Ford introduces Harper as his “new fishing partner”, to which Mr. Harper takes the stage (l...
by Steven
1

 

 
uk-db

UK Threatens End To Foreign Aid Over Anti-Gay Policies

It is rare for me to ever support anything that is anti-gay. In fact, it has never happened. So, with the news that the UK may discontinue providing foreign aid to countries that have anti-gay legislation, I should be cracking ...
by Dallas
3

 
 
alison redford alberta premier

Yeehaw! Alberta Elects Feminist Female Premier Who Maybe Likes HomoGays

In a province that celebrates calf-roping and Wranglers, and smells of horse manure after a day of rain we never would have thought the day would come. Well, (r)evolution is upon us here in the Wild Rose province as our new Pre...
by Dallas
5

 
 
please

Transphobic Ad in National Post Bites Institute for Canadian Values in Tight White Asses

If you have been on Facebook in the last 24 hours you have undoubtedly by now come across numerous posts about this transphobic ad in the National Post.  Sponsored by the ‘National Think-Tank’ promoting Christian-J...
by Dallas
2

 




One Comment


  1. Good Evening:

    First of all, I really want to thank you for such a heart wrenching article.

    Secondly I want to say that your words hit very very close to the situations I have lived in, and am presently living in. Felling alone and at times going through so much stress because of financial issues, relationship issues, employment issues and most importantly giving up hope in my Creator – I stopped praying with my Sweetgrass.

    A few years ago I felt like this and I used alcohol to kill the loneliness I felt, today it is drug use. I made to feel lower than low, by my partner and worst of all by myself.

    He came into my life when i needed someone to help me through the a part of my life when i NEEDED someone there. I was going through HepC treatments at the time, also I was fearing of losing my job which I loved so very much, I did lose a job and a shunned from the Society for a few reasons, Maily I spoke up when I saw issues of mismanagement. Anyhoo, for 3 months he cooked, cleaned and CARED for me. He was there when the pain hit and held me. That was 2 1/2 years ago, since then we moved in together and this past year was when this relationship started to change for the worse.

    When I worked he did all the cleaning, and it felt good to have someone prepare food and take care of you. I am also HIV+ (19.5years), and being co-infected did not seem to bother him he accepted me for me.

    This past year was when the verbal abuse started. It can be hard one day he can be fun and sweet and very caring for me – cooking and cleaning the majority of the time. The next day he can be so mean and yell and scare the hell out of me where i sit so very still as not to make noise. I would go into the opposite room he would be in and stay there until he either left or came in to apologize, but i knew it would happen again, i always hoped it would not but – it always does.

    A couple of weeks ago, I am sad to admit, we were using and somehow we got into an argument and then we hit each other. I am not sure how it started, or who hot who first. I know just know that i was so terrified that night. It was that night I realized that I HAVE GOT TO GET OUT OF HERE.

    I was sad on my birthday, Oct. 5th, I found myself sitting in a social workers office looking for a shelter to stay in until things cooled or until i got my own place. What was offered to me was a Homeless Shelter – it hurt when the worker told me that was “ONLY PLACE AVAILABLE.” So what I did I came home and told him about my day, and I said that if we can just stay calm and treat each other with respect we can make it through this month.

    I have made arrangements/deal with a First Nations Housing Society, but I will not have a FREEDOM HOME until Dec.1st. My part of the arrangement /deal is to go home to be with my family and get grounded again and heal my mind, heart and most of all my Spirit. I miss my family a lot. I also start a new HepC treatment, it does care me a little. But what does me the strength to face it alone (not really alone have Family & Family), is the happiness I will have when I am alone and FREE.

    With all of this going on there is something that hurt more since I left that Social Workers office. NO PLACE for gay, lesbian, trans, bi or 2-Spirit to find that safe place for the night or even a week. I have begun thinking and doing some research.

    Years ago I regained my VOICE by attending Male Sexual Abuse therapy. It was that voice and an attitude that got me notice and at times in trouble, but I used my voice to speak up when no one would. I feel that when I am finally out of this lovingly abusive relationship I will do something about “NO PLACE TO GO.” Any thoughts on how to start?

    Thank you again so much for touching my heart and Spirit tonight

    May Creator be with you each and step of your Journey.

    Maistoo’a Waastaan (Crow Flag)
    Rodney L. M.



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *