Stevie's Spin

September 30, 2011

Stevie’s Spin: Is Facebook to Windows as Google+ is to Apple OS X?

More articles by »
Written by: Steve
Tags: , , , , , ,
Social Media Smackdown

It’s A Social Smackdown

Remember when Microsoft ruled the world? Me, neither. But it did. Windows was ubiquitous and while a mainstream user might have had complaints, they were tethered to the giant; the only game in town. There was little motivation to innovate when you had a virtual monopoly. While nerds and artists embraced Linux and Mac, the average user didn’t know that there was a better option.

Along came Apple’s OS X and the game changed. The UNIX-based OS served the core needs of the user, gave them next-generation iterations of the features they were used to having and also made it clean, intuitive, elegant – even cool. On top of polished base functionality, add a host of options you didn’t know you wanted until you had them, and a revolution was born.

Compare this analogy to the current social network giant, Facebook and scrappy newcomer, Google+. While it may seem patently absurd to consider Google an underdog in any arena, their sketchy track record with Social combined with the sheer magnitude of taking on the 750,000,000 member-strong collosus, makes the effort a steep upward climb.

Facebook is to Windows as Google+ is to OS X

Geeks and enthusiasts were onboard immediately and when the doors recently opened to the public, traffic spiked 1269% for the week ending September 17th to the week of September 24th.

The query is now, “Will Google+ supplant Facebook?” Only time will tell, though this is unlikely for a number of reasons. Firstly, while the comparison of Facebook’s usurping of MySpace is frequently referenced here, there are marked differences. My Space, while massively popular, had not woven into the fabric of our daily lives and expanded to users traditionally considered too unsavvy to embrace social networking. Facebook has. Most of us have parents (or grandparents!) who commonly log on. Secondly, millions of users have chronicled years of their lives on Facebook and while you can download a static archive of all your content and take it with you, you lose the structure and context Facebook provides.

This isn’t to say that Facebook isn’t reacting. In fact, some recent privacy and sharing updates, in their panicked catch-up-with-the-new-kid tone, have been downright MySpacey.

Facebook Timeline

Facebook’s return volley hasn’t been entirely derivative, however. Leveraging something that Google simply can’t compete with – years of your life in pictures and posts – Zucks and co have launched the compelling Timeline feature, offering an interactive chronology of your life through the lens of Facebook. Concerns over privacy and exposure aside, it packs a powerful nostalgic punch and may generate some affection for the network.

History tends to repeat when not observed. In a world where Microsoft has yet to deliver a version of Windows that lives up to promises and press releases, the pressure is now on Facebook to defend its status as social king while Google revels in a creative boom.

About the Author

[Geekdom contributor] Steve "StevieSpin" Lunny is a NYC-based digital media designer originally from Montreal. When not working on interactive media and motion graphics at his day job, Steve is designing mobile apps and games by night for his startup StevieSpin Digital Media.



Stevie’s Spin: Apple’s New iPad

Apple’s new iPad is upon us. Does it deliver? The bar is so astoundingly high for Apple that anything less than jaw-dropping translates to a disappointment. So where does the new iPad fall? When the iPhone 4s was released las...
by Steve


How Steve Jobs Empowered a Generation

I was in the trenches when D&D and comics were still wedgie-worthy and sci-fi was light-years from trendy. The past decade has seen the advent of the geek, from social misfit and misanthrope in the eyes of mainstream folk,...
by Steve


RIP Steve Jobs, We Love The Cool Stuff You Made #isad

First my twitter feed went ballistic announcing the unfortunate death of Steve Jobs. Then came the Facebook responses: “OMG NO!”, and “I can’t believe it…” or “Nooooo :(” and even...
by Nikki


Apple Homepage

Stevie’s Spin: With The iPhone 4s, It’s Inner Beauty That Counts

Apple’s new CEO, glass-closeted and future super-gay, Tim Cook, revealed the latest model of the beloved iPhone today. In the past 24 hours we went from expecting an iPhone 5, to perhaps both a 5 and a 4s, to actually get...
by Steve

tgb july 28

Mac Too PC, Get Well Jack, SYTYCD, Maddow Sued, Atwood For Mayor?…

Mac Too PC? and are going after Apple for their participation in the controversial Christian Values Network’s charitable giving plan whereby customers can donate a portion of their purchase from iTun...
by Erika


So, what is Google+? A PSA from your Technigay

So you have probably already heard the news, and you want to be invited to Google+ (see how at the bottom! we have invites!). Even if you haven’t heard the buzz on the interwebz, there’s a new sheriff in town goin by the na...


Facebook Ext. For Chrome.. YES YOU CAN!

When I first saw the new Google Chrome Facebook extension (version 2.0.9), my face lit up like a school girl on her sweet 16. What do you mean I can receive my fb notifications without checking out my actual Facebook page? Well...


  1. Rob

    Never thought about this before, awesome post!

  2. Deb Acle

    Damn, and I though you were just all good looks and six pack! Dude, not only you can write, but you can analyze the shit out of social media! WOW! Are you single?

  3. Awesome article, Steve, but I’ll do you one better. Google+ : Facebook = Google : Apple. Android, ChomeOS, Google Music, the Docs suite, and other recent Google ventures seem squarely aimed at positioning Google in the #2 spot relative to Microsoft somewhere down the road. With the complete integration of an explosively popular social network, I can’t help but wonder if Apple might soon be relegated once again to being just a company that makes fancy computers and really nice MP3 players.

  4. Lesley Darman

    I am totally impressed with the quality of the writing and the knowledge behind it… good, clean graphics and a streamlined look overall. les

  5. Ty

    Love this post Steve!

  6. Jim

    Spot on (and I love “Zucks”)!

  7. melanie ann

    fb is cooler than windows! do you really think google+ has potential beyond novelty? I think people are comfy where they are, and will have a hard time switching over.

    • I am finding this. I signed up for google+, think it is cool, but… chirp, chirp.. .nothing is really happening, and I really have no issues with facebook, and they are really improving with their lists to compare to circles which was one of the main draws.

  8. Steve

    Some will but considering Google+ is barely out of the wrapper and is cresting 50,000,000 users, populating the network is a non-issue.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *